Monday 16 February 2015

Ministerial Impunity needs serious redress!



When the Democratic Progressive Party launched their second coming into government, the inaugural speech contained the statement of promise for appointments and performance assessment based on merit. The State President made a vivid and audible proclamation that he shall not favour or support any individual on other grounds apart from merit and professionalism. The speech proceeded to state that the president shall fire any minister who has failed to perform and replace him/her with one who is ready to perform. This sentiment was welcomed by an applause of hope and aspiration. Malawi is a country that has been at the tail in development progress subject to its nepotistic and patrimonial tendencies. We have had sour grapes to reminisce in the name of non-performing appointees cushioned by the higher authority. In this blog, I will try to recall these ministers with impunity, who relished the higher authority and sustained their stay. I will also state on the current status and conclude on whether we are making progress or not.

During the UDF era, we had a couple of non-performing ministers with impunity. Whose mediocrity was outstanding and outrageous, yet had signed a more permanent contract agreement, as it sounds to me. The most notable was the late Honourable Dumbo Lemani, who had the longest stay without a trophy to glory of except personal wealth. Many were taunted and even other physically assaulted but his stay in the ministering positions was something we all could nominate to be one of the seven wonders of surprises in the world. The second of his nature was Honourable Lilian Patel who similarly served in different portfolios as a minister, and was renowned to have lambasted the Danish ambassador that he did not matter and he should not have any statement in Malawian affairs or he can pack up and go, reminiscent of the ‘persona non grata’ incident that occurred in 2009, yet she was only a minister.  The era had lots of handclappers, bootlickers, name-praisers, and very incompetent ministers serving and running the affairs of our country. The Honourable George Mtafu had his show and several other ministers took changes on the ministerial stage. The minister had his craziest moments in the parliament, even when he adamantly jested the then Speaker, Rodwell Munyenyembe, with the statement: ‘You must be stupid’! The aftermaths of which, fate knows best what caused it, but characteristic of national tragedy, yet never drilled some sense in the ‘sane but crazy’ minister.

During the DPP era, the tendency survived, subject to the fact that most ministers that had been in UDF were resurfacing in DPP. The many ministers had practically crossed the floor after unilaterally declaring themselves to belong to the ruling party. The ministerial impunity continued. We had ministers had not performed but still maintained their portfolios or were simply switched from one ministerial position to the next. We saw an exchange of brawls between ministers in parliament and a number of other uncharacteristic events in the era. The public had another episode of ministerial swordplay and caricature. The stage had slightly changed as we noted that then president demonstrated cautioned at some intervals and he was undetermined in his next course of action. But it remained to be seen if ministerial impunity and failure to address the most critical angles of our development were defiantly visible.

During the PP era the same legacy remained unabated. We seem to be making two steps forward and five steps backwards. The plausible direction we need to take is the direction where our ministers are going to be assessed on performance basis and performance ratings will determine their stay as ministers. Of late, we have seen worrisome of some ministerial performance, notably that of the Former Minister of Internal Affairs, Honourable Uladi Mussa, ‘Change Golo’ as he was famously called. The minster gave a joke of our lifetime when he stated through the media houses that he was willing to talk to those who had security concerns through his number, thereby providing the number to the public. The minister remain defiant that the nation was facing security crisis when when countless evidence were on display through the same media. It was to my surprise that the minister had stay longer than we expected. I would do myself a disfavour, if I do not talk about the former Minister of Finance, Honourable Ken Lipenga, who had to become a silent lamb for the sins of ministerial impunity at a later stage. Parliamentary hansards had recorded him to have lied to the nation to sugarcoat the Zero-deficit budget in 2011, a year earlier, before his bet met his fate. The minister paid a heavy cost through a cabinet shuffle that followed immediately after he had become a liability to the PP government which wanted to appease the donor community. There are many ministerial stories that speak the same message of ministerial impunity.

Currently, whilst the nation is building or rebuilding its trust in the current leadership, it is imperative that leadership considers walking the talk, very very seriously. The ministerial performance assessment as has been proposed by the current Public Sector Reform project is a very welcome idea and needs to be promptly implemented. The president must set new standards of accountability, where we will not only see new policies and new conditions being formulated, but new policies and conditions been seen to be implemented. The call for a shaking to our nations is a higher toll that needs no overemphasizing. The current status of public social service requires meritorious professionals, and prudent ministers and principal secretaries. The state at which the nation is in, where we still have to secure a reliable source of financial resources, leaves no room for appeasement. The state where we need to consider vision about ambition, where personal gratification is that last matter to attend to. The nation has been on its knees economically and we need to prick ourselves in the areas, that will make us reduce on fun and stand up to the call! Then we shall be remembered. I speak in consideration of the ministry of education, where teachers have had no pay since last year, and it basically is lamentable that the situation has come to this far. We may not immediately condemn the minister responsible must be seen concerned. The Ministry of Education is the most critical ministry for development, last thing we can do as a nation is to sink down our educational standards. We need to immediately draw resources to this ministry and find out what is delaying teachers’ salaries and address it once and for all! Nobody would work without pay comfortably. We are already hit by the rising costs of living standards, even prices of basic needs are souring high on the market, and if a teacher will fail to buy a packet of sugar, how shall he or she teach about economic development.

MAY GOD CONTINUE TO BLESS OUR MOTHER LAND, MALAWI, THE ONLY COUNTRY WE HAVE!